Latest PCC Report Fails Own Ambition

In his recent Annual Report, Press Complaints Commission chair, Sir Christopher Meyer, asserted “the near universal incorporation of the [Editors’] Code of Practice in journalists’ contracts”. From his just-published report on the News of the World illegal phone-tapping scandal, Subterfuge and Newsgathering (see here), it is clear that this is far from the case.

The rather odd claim – that a Code devised by and for Editors is part of ordinary journalists’ contracts – has been made by the Press Complaints Commission (PCC), and challenged by [the media ethics charity] MediaWise, on numerous occasions.

Working journalists and their organisations are not permitted to be part of the PCC nor the Editors’ Code Committee run by the Press Board of Finance (PressBof) which funds the PCC. What is more, few editors or proprietors have ever been willing to recognise the Code of Conduct to which the National Union of Journalists’ (NUJ) members have been signing up since

And both the PCC and employers organisations have resisted calls to include a ’conscience clause’ in employment contracts to protect journalists who take an ethical stand. To them, Sir Christopher’s demand will sound like another stick with which they can be bashed by editors who are ultimately responsible for what is published.

In the past, Sir Christopher has been anxious to distance the PCC from ‘industrial issues’. From this report, it is clear that he expects journalists to face the sack for breaches of the Code. Yet, how many editors have been sacked for breaching the Code? Some of the worst offenders have even served on the PCC itself.

If the Editor’s Code is to be included in employment contracts, then natural justice requires that journalists and their organisations should be involved in devising and policing the Code, and that a measure of protection should be given to journalists who refuse instructions or assignments that they believe might be in breach of their own ethical standards.

Sir Christopher promises free PCC training and a special seminar this summer as part of his move to reduce the likelihood of improper behaviour by journalists. Elsewhere, he has flagged up the possibility of closer engagement with the broadcasting regulator, Ofcom, now that the PCC has extended its remit to include podcasts and streamed video on the websites of
publications. His justification is the enhancement of public trust in journalistic integrity.

This laudable aim will ring hollow with print journalists required to comply with the demands of managements whose primary aims are commercial. Working under extreme competitive and time pressures, they are expected to increase sales and advertising revenue by producing stories for print and online editions, and some must even produce moving images.

Some local newspaper reporters are expected live on